![](https://tempestmag.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/brian_response_oct_7_feature_card-700x476.jpeg)
What solidarity requires
A response to Mel Bienenfeld on October 7
by brian beanbrian bean replies to Mel Bienenfeld’s criticism of two earlier Tempest articles by the author on the analysis and posture of revolutionary socialists towards the events of October 7 in Palestine.